Blogs

How to Tell Who Sideswiped Who: Key Tips for Determining Fault

Understanding sideswipe collisions 

A sideswipe collision occurs when two vehicles traveling in the same or opposite direction make contact along their sides. These incidents frequently happen during lane changes, merges or when one vehicle drifts out of its lane. Common causes include distracted driving, blindspot mistakes, improper merges and aggressive behavior on highways or busy city streets. Sideswipes may appear minor because the initial impact often produces a streak of paint or a shallow dent. In reality, the sudden sideways force can jerk occupants’ heads and torsos, leading to neck strains, softtissue injuries, concussions and spinal trauma. When large vehicles such as trucks or buses sideswipe a smaller car, the disparity in weight can push the smaller vehicle into adjacent lanes or off the roadway, causing secondary crashes. 

Typical scenarios and highrisk situations 

Most sideswipe collisions fall into a handful of predictable patterns. Understanding these scenarios helps clarify who may be at fault: 

  • Unsafe lane changes: Drivers who fail to check blind spots, signal properly or yield to vehicles already occupying a lane often sideswipe while merging or passing. Traffic laws usually require signalling for a prescribed distance (for example, Texas law mandates signalling for at least 100 feet before changing lanes) and yielding to vehicles already in the lane. 

 

  • Drifting due to distraction: A driver distracted by a mobile phone, passengers or fatigue may drift into an adjacent lane without realizing it. Evidence such as phone records or dashcam footage can help show the driver was not paying attention. 

 

  • Simultaneous lane changes: When two drivers attempt to merge into the same lane at the same time, fault may be shared. Comparative negligence rules allocate liability according to each driver’s actions; the driver who failed to check blind spots or signal properly often bears greater responsibility. 

 

  • Merging onto highways: Entrants must yield to existing traffic. Failing to yield when merging from an onramp often places blame on the merging driver. 

 

  • Commercial vehicle sideswipes: Trucks and buses have large blind spots. Professional drivers must exercise extra caution when changing lanes; failure to do so can make them or their employers liable for inadequate training or failure to maintain mirrors. When a smaller car is sideswiped by a commercial vehicle, the impact can be devastating. 

 

Certain road conditions increase the risk of sideswipes. Congested urban streets with narrow lanes, highways with high traffic volumes and multilane highways with frequent interchanges make it easier for drivers to misjudge distances. Weather also plays a role; rain or ice can cause a vehicle to hydroplane into an adjacent lane. Aggressive driving and road rage can lead to intentionally cutting off another driver, causing a sideswipe. Knowing these risk factors can help drivers remain vigilant and avoid such collisions. 

Why determining fault is challenging 

Unlike rearend collisions, where the trailing driver is often presumed liable, sideswipe accidents rarely produce clearcut evidence. Both drivers may claim they stayed in their lane while the other drifted or merged. Paint transfers and scrapes appear on both cars, making it hard to identify the direction of movement. Investigators therefore rely on a combination of physical evidence, witness accounts and legal standards to establish liability. 

Evidence used to establish fault 

Police reports and witness statements: Officers who respond to the accident document driver statements, traffic violations and conditions at the scene. Independent witnesses nearby drivers, pedestrians or security cameras can provide unbiased accounts of which car crossed into another lane. Witness testimonies often carry weight when drivers’ stories conflict. 

Traffic laws: Violations of lanechange regulations strongly influence fault. Drivers must signal for a prescribed distance, ensure the lane is clear and yield appropriately. Failing to comply can constitute negligence. Drifting out of a lane due to distraction, fatigue or impairment is also considered negligent. 

Damage patterns and accident reconstruction: The location and pattern of damage on the vehicles can indicate which driver veered into the other’s lane. Damage concentrated along the left side of one car and the right side of the other suggests the left vehicle crossed into the right lane. Accident reconstruction experts analyze skid marks, paint transfers and vehicle positioning to determine the sequence of events. 

Driver behavior and records: Evidence such as phone logs, surveillance footage, GPS data and citations for speeding or distracted driving can prove recklessness. If a driver was cited for running a red light or failing to yield before the collision, that citation becomes key evidence. 

State comparative negligence rules: Fault determination may be influenced by state laws. For example, New Jersey applies a modified comparative negligence rule that bars recovery if a driver is more than 50 % at fault. New York follows pure comparative negligence, meaning a driver can recover damages even if they are mostly at fault, though compensation is reduced proportionally. Understanding local laws helps victims gauge potential compensation. 

Injuries and damages in sideswipe accidents 

The sudden lateral forces in a sideswipe can cause serious injuries. Common injuries include whiplash, softtissue strains, traumatic brain injuries, spinal injuries, fractures and psychological trauma. Symptoms may not appear immediately; they can develop hours or days after the crash, so prompt medical evaluation is essential. Damages often extend beyond medical bills and vehicle repairs. Victims may experience lost income, reduced earning capacity, chronic pain and emotional distress. Proving these damages typically requires medical records, bills, employment documentation and expert testimony. 

Steps to take after a sideswipe accident 

  1. Ensure safety and call 911. Pull over to a safe location if possible, turn on hazard lights and check for injuries. Calling the police ensures the crash is documented and emergency services are dispatched if needed. 
  1. Exchange information and gather evidence. Exchange names, contact details, driver’s license numbers and insurance information with the other driver. Take photos of vehicle damage, skid marks, road conditions and any contributing factors (e.g., obscured signage). Obtain contact information for witnesses. 
  1. Seek medical attention. Even if injuries seem minor, get evaluated promptly. A doctor’s report provides evidence that injuries were caused by the crash. 
  1. Report the accident to your insurer. Promptly notify your insurance company. Provide factual details but avoid making statements that could be interpreted as admitting fault. 
  1. Consult an attorney. Because sideswipe cases involve contested facts and complex evidence, an experienced caraccident attorney can gather records, interview witnesses, work with reconstruction experts and negotiate with insurers. Lawyers can also advise on comparative fault rules and pursue litigation if insurers refuse a fair settlement. 

Legal considerations and the role of attorneys 

Accident attorneys play a critical role in sideswipe cases. They secure timesensitive evidence, such as surveillance footage and vehicledata recorder information, before it disappears. They handle negotiations with insurance adjusters, who may downplay sideswipe collisions or attempt to shift blame. Lawyers also prepare legal arguments based on negligence principles showing that the other driver failed to signal, yielded improperly or drove distracted. In the event of shared fault, attorneys can argue that the other party’s negligence outweighs your own, maximizing potential compensation. When necessary, attorneys file lawsuits and represent clients in court, presenting expert testimony and challenging insurance tactics. 

Comparative negligence and compensation 

Under comparative negligence rules, each driver’s percentage of fault reduces the damages they can recover. For example, if you are deemed 30 % at fault and your damages total $50,000, your award would be reduced to $35,000. This underscores why thorough evidence collection and expert analysis are vital: demonstrating that the other driver’s negligence is greater can significantly affect your recovery. 

Conclusion 

Sideswipe collisions can have serious consequences, even when the visible damage seems minor. Because both drivers often claim the other caused the crash, determining fault requires a careful review of evidence, an understanding of traffic laws and sometimes the expertise of accident reconstruction specialists. Drivers should avoid unsafe lane changes, eliminate distractions and watch for blind spots to reduce their risk of causing a sideswipe. If you’re involved in such an accident, documenting the scene, seeking medical attention and consulting an attorney are crucial steps toward protecting your rights and securing fair compensation. Guardian Core Solution partners with experienced caraccident attorneys across the country. We can connect you with a lawyer who will investigate the crash, deal with insurance companies and fight for the compensation you deserve. 

References 

  1. Article explaining typical causes of sideswipe collisions and why they can cause severe injuries, noting that contact between vehicles often occurs during lane changes or mergingmaggianolaw.com. 
  1. Houston law firm guide discussing key evidence in sideswipe cases, including police reports, witness statements, lanechange laws, damage patterns and the role of accident reconstruction expertssjinjuryattorneys.com. 
  1. Explanation of common scenarios in sideswipe collisions—simultaneous lane changes, drifting due to distraction, merging onto highways and commercial vehicle sideswipes—and how comparative negligence rules assign faultsjinjuryattorneys.com. 
  1. Discussion of how injuries like whiplash, softtissue damage, traumatic brain injuries and psychological trauma can result from sideswipe accidentsmaggianolaw.com. 
  1. Overview of comparative negligence laws in New Jersey and New York and how they affect compensation when both drivers share faultmaggianolaw.com.